• TranscendentalEmpire@lemmy.today
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    5 hours ago

    How do you define “primary source”? The section I quoted was written by someone who knew Jesus personally

    It’s a reinterpretation of oral accounts passed down decades after the deaths of the people it’s about, and was first attributed to John nearly 180 years later. The gospel of John was first authored anonymously around 90-100ad and attributed to John by Irenaeus in 185ad

    That is definitely contemporary for accounts at this point in history.

    Not really, contemporary sources are generally limited to people involved with the actual history.

    A lot of what we know about other people were written down centuries after.

    When combined with other contextual sources.

    Okay then, do you have any evidence on the contrary? That those weren’t His motivations?

    I’m not the one making the claim that other religions are wrong and Christianity is true. Do you have evidence that Joseph Smith, Muhammad, or Buddha had alternative motives?

    What temple did He destroy? The temple was destroyed in 70AD

    I meant the first time… Not literally destroyed, but trashed, fucked dudes up, flipped tables.